Can a Countertop Oven Replace Your Air Fryer? Breville vs. Ninja

Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro and Ninja Prestige Pro XL shown side by side with their published widths

To decide whether a countertop oven can replace your air fryer, start with the pan you reach for on a busy night. If you usually want pizza, toast, or vegetables spread across a tray, a larger oven might do more for you than another basket. The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro BOV900 and Ninja Prestige Pro XL DT551 both include an air-fry basket, but their included gear and operating space matter more than the number of cooking modes.

Who it’s for. Lean Breville if compatibility with a 9-by-13-inch pan is your priority. Lean Ninja if a cook thermometer and the included pair of sheet pans suit the meals you make most. Think twice before replacing a basket fryer you use mainly for quick single portions.

This guide compares published specifications and owner information. The cover pairs catalog photos using listed widths, and the food scene is an AI-generated illustration.

At a glance

DetailBreville Smart Oven Air Fryer ProNinja Prestige Pro XL
ModelBOV900DT551
Listed exterior21.4 W × 17.3 D × 12.7 H in19.84 × 17.09 × 13.35 in per Ninja
Included air-fry accessoryMesh basketAir-fry basket
Included pansPizza pan and roasting panTwo sheet pans
Why pick it?Documented 9-by-13-inch pan fit and 13-inch pizza accessoryIncluded Pro Cook thermometer and two-level layout

Shop by the pan, not the preset

Breville publishes support for a 9-by-13-inch baking pan and includes a 13-inch pizza pan. Check whether your dish has handles: the measurement stamped on the bottom usually isn’t the widest point. Even when the pan fits, you need enough room to guide it onto the rack with mitts.

Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro in brushed stainless steel with a closed glass door

Ninja includes two sheet pans and two wire racks, so this model makes a clear case if you want to work with the accessories designed for it. Treat the supplied pan as your starting point. Before assuming a particular dish from your full-size oven will fit, check its outside dimensions against the oven’s usable space.

Measure the counter while the door is open

A closed appliance can fit a counter and still make dinner awkward. Pick a spot where you can lower the door and slide a hot pan straight out. Remember to leave a separate place to set that pan down. Check the installation clearances in the manual and account for the plug and the cabinet above before buying.

Ninja Prestige Pro XL DT551 stainless countertop oven

Breville lists a 21.4-inch width and 17.3-inch depth. Ninja’s 19.84-by-17.09-inch published horizontal measurements put it in a similar size class. If the difference is the only reason one model fits your space on paper, verify the exact SKU and clearances before ordering.

When it can replace a basket air fryer

A countertop oven earns its spot if your weekly routine includes jobs a basket does poorly, such as baking a pizza or toasting several slices at once. Its tray also makes it easier to lay food out in a broad layer. An integrated probe like the one supplied with the Ninja is most relevant when you roast food and want to follow its internal temperature.

Pizza on a round pan beside a rectangular tray of roast vegetables on a stone counter

Keep a basket-style unit in the running if your usual job is a small side, reheating leftovers, or making snacks for one. A pull-out drawer can be easier to handle for that routine, and a dual-basket model is worth considering when the main and side need different settings at the same time.

Check current prices

Affiliate disclosure. We may earn a commission if you make a qualifying purchase through this link.

Affiliate disclosure. We may earn a commission if you make a qualifying purchase through this link.

For smaller meals, see the COSORI TurboBlaze single-basket guide and the COSORI vs. Ninja DualZone comparison.

Sources. Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro official specifications, Ninja Prestige Pro XL official specifications, Breville BOV900 instruction manual.

Checking doneness or comparing counter space? Read our instant-read vs. wireless meat thermometer guide and Vitamix vs. Ninja blender comparison.